Pride and Prejudice

Balancing Milestones and Critical Inquiry

Napoleon Bonaparte, the legendary emperor of France, offered a thought-provoking perspective on medicine when he said, “Medicine is not an exact and positive science but a science based on conjectures and observations. I would have more confidence in a physician who has not studied the natural sciences than in one who has.”1 This insight encourages us to reflect, especially as we explore the evolving fields of periodontology and implantology, which have made tremendous strides over the past few decades.

In recent years, we have seen incredible clinical success in these areas, thanks to the unwavering dedication to scientific inquiry and the tireless innovation of passionate researchers. It’s inspiring to note how our collective efforts have significantly enhanced patients’ quality of life through the preservation of periodontal health and the restoration of missing teeth. These achievements truly highlight our profession’s positive impact on dental medicine, and we have much to be proud of.

Yet, while celebrating our successes, it’s also essential to engage in thoughtful reflection. Are we fully justified in basking in our accomplishments when numerous fundamental questions remain to be explored?

Even as periodontology has evolved from focusing primarily on repair to embracing a regeneration-centered approach, we still face challenges in identifying the true etiological factors and mechanisms behind periodontal disease. This ongoing quest for knowledge is essential not just for enhancing our diagnostic and therapeutic skills but also for deepening our understanding of periodontal health.

Similarly, the breakthroughs in dental implantology, led by the pioneering work of Dr. Per-Ingvar Brånemark, have gained widespread recognition among dental professionals and patients alike. Implants are now celebrated as reliable solutions for replacing missing teeth and offer remarkable functional and aesthetic benefits. However, as we see increasing adoption of implant therapy, we must also address the associated rise in peri-implantitis—an inflammatory condition that affects the gums and supporting tissues around implants. The challenge of effectively managing or curing this condition underscores the vital need for more diligent monitoring and research in this field.

It’s critical not to become complacent in the face of these challenges, as such an attitude could hinder our shared commitment to advancing scientific understanding. Complacency can lead to biases where one treatment option is favored over others without robust scientific evidence to back it up.

To invigorate our approach, we can draw wisdom from Dr. Claude Bernard, a distinguished 19th-century French physiologist who wisely said, “To conserve health and to cure disease: Medicine is still pursuing a scientific solution to this problem, which has confronted it from the first.”2 His words remind us that the quest for knowledge is at the very heart of the medical field.

With this perspective, we can celebrate periodontology and implantology as vital components of periodontal and implant science. This issue of the Journal of Periodontal & Implant Science features five exciting research articles and three informative case reports that contribute significantly to our understanding and advancement in these vital fields.3 We warmly invite you to dive into the insights presented in this issue, as they are crucial for driving progress in periodontal and implant science, ultimately leading to improved patient care and outcomes.

Together, let’s look forward to exploring these advancements and continuing to enhance our practices for the benefit of our patients and the wider community.

Elaborating on the original publication:

https://doi.org/10.5051/jpis.2010.40.2.47

References

1. O’Meara BE. Napoleon in Exile: A Voice from St Helena. Vol. 1. Philadelphia (PA): H C Carey & I Lea, 1822.

2. Bernard C. Introduction à l’étude de la médecine expérimentale. Paris: J-B Baillière et Fils, 1865.

3. J Periodontal Implant Sci 2010;40(2). Available from: https://jpis.org/LinkX.php?code=1150JPIS&vol=40&issue=2